How to Transcribe Audio to Sheet Music (MIDI, MusicXML, Piano Roll)
Converting a song to sheet music sounds simple until you try it: upload an MP3 to a generic audio-to-MIDI tool and the result is a wall of ghost notes. The drum kit, the bass line, the pad — every sound in the mix gets written down as if it were melody. The transcription is technically 'correct' and completely useless.
Why transcribing a full mix fails
Automatic music transcription (AMT) is one of the oldest unsolved problems in music information retrieval. The best academic systems reach roughly 85–95% note accuracy — and only on clean solo-piano recordings. On a real mix the physics works against you: percussion produces broadband noise that pitch trackers read as false onsets, and two instruments playing an octave apart share almost all of their harmonics, so they can't be told apart in the spectrum.
That is why the first step matters more than the model: separate the part you actually want before any note tracking happens.
Separation first, transcription second
KROMA's Transcribe mode runs a 6-stem separation model (vocals / drums / bass / guitar / piano / remaining music) and lets you pick which part to score. The note tracker — Spotify's Basic Pitch neural network, running as ONNX inference — only ever hears that one isolated part, so almost every note it writes down actually belongs to the line you asked for.
The result is a downloadable package containing three files: a .mid you can drop into any DAW, a .musicxml score that opens in MuseScore/Finale/Sibelius quantized to the detected tempo, and a piano-roll PNG so you can eyeball the detection before spending time in notation software.
What it can and cannot do
Honest expectations: clear single-line melodies — a lead vocal, a bass line, a solo — transcribe well. Dense polyphonic piano chords are approximated (same-onset notes merge into chords), breathy or extremely fast passages may quantize coarsely, and residual bleed from separation can leave occasional stray notes. The MIDI keeps raw timing, so cleanup in a DAW or MuseScore is fast.
You can also transcribe just a section — set a start and end time and only that passage is separated and scored, which is the fastest way to check whether your track is a good candidate.
Opening the files
The .mid file works in every DAW (Logic, FL Studio, Ableton, GarageBand). The .musicxml opens in MuseScore (free), Finale, Sibelius and Dorico. No special software is needed to view the piano-roll PNG. A README.txt inside the zip explains each file.